Slice of Toledo, Ohio: Here Are The City’s Top 10 Pizzerias

Ever found yourself wandering the streets of Toledo, craving a slice of cheesy goodness? You’re in luck! Toledo boasts a pizza scene that’s both rich in flavor and history. From the crispy thin crusts to the gooey deep dishes, this city has it all.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. “Another top 10 pizzeria article? Really?” But trust me, Toledo’s pizza game stands out in a league of its own. It’s not just about the toppings or the cheese; it’s about the passion and tradition that goes into every pie.

So, whether you’re a local looking to rediscover your city’s pizza gems or a traveler eager for a taste of Toledo, this guide’s for you. Let’s dive deep into the world of Toledo pizza and uncover the best slices in town!

Pizzeria	Address	Phone Number	Specialty	Ambiance
Wild Side Downtown	20 N St Clair St, Toledo, OH 43604	(419) 830-3044	Artisanal Pizzas	Downtown, Trendy
Mama Mary’s Pizza – Toledo	6725 Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43617	(567) 833-6000	Spicy Pepperoni Pizza	Cozy, Family-friendly
Dandino’s Pizza & More	4804 Lewis Ave, Toledo, OH 43612	(419) 407-5526	Diverse Menu	Community-focused, Casual
Vito’s Pizza and Subs	4035 Navarre Ave, Oregon, OH 43616	(419) 697-8486	Classic Pizzas	Traditional, Welcoming
Salute Pizzeria	5155 Glendale Ave, Toledo, OH 43614	(419) 407-5516	Fusion Pizzas	Modern, Innovative
Wild Side Brewing Company	24194 Front St, Grand Rapids, OH 43522	(419) 830-3044	Pizzas & Brews	Rustic, Brewery Setting
Pizza Pub 516	27072 Carronade Dr, Perrysburg, OH 43551	(419) 874-7773	Classic Thin Crusts	Lively, Music Nights
J & G Pizza Palace	5692 Main St, Sylvania, OH 43560	(419) 882-6061	Family Recipes	Historic, Time-honored
Blaze Pizza	3330 W Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43606	(419) 463-9274	Customizable Pizzas	Fast-casual, Contemporary
The Original Ginos Pizza	3981 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43620	(419) 472-3567	Deep-dish Pizzas	Classic, Hearty

History of Pizza in Toledo, Ohio

Hey, did you ever wonder how Toledo became such a hotspot for pizza? Let’s take a quick trip down memory lane.

Origins of Toledo’s Pizza Passion

Back in the day, as immigrants made Toledo their home, they brought with them the art of pizza-making. And oh boy, did Toledoans fall in love! The city embraced this delicious dish, adding its own twist and flavor. Over time, Toledo became a melting pot of pizza styles, each telling its own story.

Evolution of the Slice

From the classic Margherita to innovative gourmet toppings, Toledo’s pizza scene has seen it all. Local pizzerias constantly experiment, ensuring there’s always something new to try. And guess what? The city’s pizza evolution isn’t slowing down. With every generation, there’s a fresh take on this beloved dish, making sure Toledo stays on the pizza map!

The Best Pizzerias in Toledo

Toledo’s pizza scene is vibrant, diverse, and downright delicious. But with so many options, where should you start? Don’t worry; I’ve got you covered.

Here’s a handpicked list of the best pizzerias in town, each offering a unique slice of heaven.

Wild Side Downtown

Address: 20 N St Clair St, Toledo, OH 43604 Phone: (419) 830-3044

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Craft beers and artisanal pizzas.

Nestled in the heart of downtown Toledo, Wild Side offers more than just pizza; it’s an experience. With their artisanal approach to pizza-making, every slice is a masterpiece. The crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are fresh, and the ambiance? Simply unbeatable. Whether you’re catching up with friends or on a romantic date, Wild Side Downtown sets the mood right.

Mama Mary’s Pizza – Toledo

Address: 6725 Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43617 Phone: (567) 833-6000

• Pricing: $ (Affordable)
• Specialty: Traditional pizzas with a wide range of toppings.

Mama Mary’s is where tradition meets modern flavors. Drawing inspiration from classic Italian recipes, they’ve added a Toledo twist to their pizzas. The result? A mouthwatering fusion that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. And if you’re in the mood for something spicy, their signature spicy pepperoni pizza is a must-try!

Dandino’s Pizza & More

Address: 4804 Lewis Ave, Toledo, OH 43612 Phone: (419) 407-5526

• Pricing: $ (Affordable)
• Specialty: Classic pizzas and Italian dishes.

Dandino’s isn’t just about pizza; it’s about community. A favorite among locals, this pizzeria offers a cozy setting where families and friends gather to enjoy hearty pizzas. Their menu is diverse, catering to all tastes. From classic Margheritas to gourmet toppings, Dandino’s ensures every palate leaves satisfied.

Vito’s Pizza and Subs

Address: 4035 Navarre Ave, Oregon, OH 43616 Phone: (419) 697-8486

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Wide variety of pizzas and subs.

Vito’s is a name synonymous with quality in Toledo. With decades of experience, they’ve perfected the art of pizza-making. Each pizza is a testament to their dedication to quality and flavor. And the best part? Their generous portions ensure you’ll have leftovers for the next day!

Salute Pizzeria

Address: 5155 Glendale Ave, Toledo, OH 43614 Phone: (419) 407-5516

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Gourmet pizzas with unique toppings.

Salute Pizzeria is where innovation meets tradition. Their chefs are constantly experimenting, introducing Toledo to new pizza flavors. But they haven’t forgotten their roots. Their traditional pizzas, made using age-old recipes, are a hit among patrons. Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or experimental, Salute Pizzeria has got you covered.

Wild Side Brewing Company

Address: 24194 Front St, Grand Rapids, OH 43522 Phone: (419) 830-3044

Don’t let the name fool you; Wild Side Brewing Company serves some of the best pizzas in town. Pair their signature pizzas with their in-house brewed beers for a match made in heaven. The rustic setting, combined with their delicious offerings, makes for a perfect evening out.

Pizza Pub 516

Address: 27072 Carronade Dr, Perrysburg, OH 43551 Phone: (419) 874-7773

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Craft beers and wood-fired pizzas.

Pizza Pub 516 is all about the classics. Their menu, inspired by traditional Italian pizzerias, offers a range of pizzas that are simple yet flavorful. Their thin crusts, combined with fresh toppings, are a treat for the taste buds. And if you’re in the mood for some live music, their regular gigs set the perfect ambiance.

J & G Pizza Palace

Address: 5692 Main St, Sylvania, OH 43560 Phone: (419) 882-6061

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Traditional pizzas in a pub setting.

J & G Pizza Palace is a testament to Toledo’s rich pizza heritage. Operating for years, they’ve become a staple in the community. Their pizzas, made using family recipes, offer a taste of history with every bite. Warm, welcoming, and delicious – that’s J & G Pizza Palace for you.

Blaze Pizza

Address: 3330 W Central Ave, Toledo, OH 43606 Phone: (419) 463-9274

• Pricing: $ (Affordable)
• Specialty: Fast-casual, customizable pizzas.

For those who like their pizzas fast and fresh, Blaze Pizza is the place to be. Their fast-casual approach ensures you get your pizza just the way you like it, and in record time! With a plethora of toppings to choose from, you can customize your pizza to your heart’s content.

The Original Ginos Pizza

Address: 3981 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43620 Phone: (419) 472-3567

• Pricing: $$ (Moderate)
• Specialty: Deep-dish pizzas and Italian favorites.

Last but not least, The Original Ginos Pizza is a Toledo legend. Their deep-dish pizzas, loaded with toppings and cheese, are a feast for the senses. If you’re looking for a hearty meal that screams comfort, Ginos is the place to be.

A Pizzeria For Every Pizza Lover

Toledo’s pizza scene is as diverse as the palates of its residents. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurer when it comes to pizza, there’s a spot in Toledo that’s perfect for you. Here’s a quick guide to help you find your pizza haven:

For the Traditionalists: If you’re all about that classic Margherita or pepperoni slice, Mama Mary’s Pizza – Toledo is your go-to. Their pizzas stick to the roots, offering that familiar taste that never gets old.

For the Gourmet Lovers: Those with a penchant for unique toppings and gourmet combinations should head straight to Salute Pizzeria. Their innovative menu promises a delightful culinary journey with every bite.

For the Craft Beer Enthusiasts: If pairing your pizza with a refreshing pint of craft beer sounds like heaven, Wild Side Downtown and Wild Side Brewing Company are your spots. Their artisanal pizzas complement their range of brews perfectly.

For the Fast and Fresh Fans: In a hurry but don’t want to compromise on taste? Blaze Pizza offers a fast-casual experience where you can customize your pizza and watch it get baked in real-time.

For the Deep-Dish Devotees: Craving that thick crust loaded with toppings and cheese? Look no further than The Original Ginos Pizza. Their deep-dish pizzas are a hearty meal in themselves.

For a Cozy Night Out: If ambiance is as important to you as the pizza itself, Dandino’s Pizza & More offers a warm, community-focused setting perfect for family dinners or catching up with friends.

In the end, no matter where you choose to dine, Toledo promises a pizza experience that’s memorable. So, follow your cravings and dive into the city’s vibrant pizza culture!

Final Thoughts

Well, there you have it, fellow pizza enthusiasts! Toledo isn’t just another city on the map; it’s a pizza paradise waiting to be explored.

From traditional family-run pizzerias to modern, innovative spots, Toledo’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious. Whether you’re a fan of the classic Margherita, a meat lover’s dream, or something entirely out of the box, Toledo has a slice with your name on it.

So, the next time you’re in town, or if you’re lucky enough to call Toledo home, make it a point to indulge in its rich pizza culture. Trust me; your taste buds will thank you.

And remember, in Toledo, every day is a good day for pizza. Cheers to many more pizza adventures in this fantastic city!

Related Questions