Best Pizzerias in Newark, New Jersey | Craving-Worthy Slices Await!

Newark, New Jersey, a city steeped in history and culture, has another feather in its cap: a thriving pizza scene that rivals any in the nation.

From the bustling streets of downtown to the quiet corners of its neighborhoods, Newark’s pizzerias serve as culinary landmarks, each telling a unique story through its flavors, ambiance, and traditions.

These establishments, some old and some new, are a testament to the city’s rich tapestry of influences, blending old-world Italian charm with modern American flair.

As you delve into this article, you’ll embark on a gastronomic journey through Newark’s most beloved pizzerias. From the classic Margheritas that evoke memories of Naples to innovative creations that push the boundaries of traditional pizza-making, Newark offers a slice for every palate.

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, a pizza connoisseur or a casual diner, this guide promises to introduce you to the very best of Newark’s pizza offerings, one bite at a time.

So, prepare your taste buds and let’s dive deep into the world of Newark’s pizza, where tradition meets innovation, and every slice tells a story.

Popular pizza establishments in Newark, NJ

Pizzeria	Address	Phone Number	Website	Notable Mention
Ellie’s Bistro	20 Green St, Newark, NJ 07102	(973) 732-2385	Visit Ellie’s Bistro	Rustic ambiance, Margherita and Prosciutto pizzas
Mulberry Street Pizza	258 Mulberry St, Newark, NJ 07102	(973) 596-0275	Visit Mulberry Street Pizza	1950s Italian trattoria, Fig and Prosciutto pizza
Brick City Bar and Grill	35 Edison Pl, Newark, NJ 07102	(973) 596-0004	Brick City Bar and Grill	BBQ Chicken pizza, Seamless online ordering
Sun Island Plate	820 S Orange Ave, Newark, NJ 07106	(973) 368-4020	Sun Island Plate	Hawaiian pizza, Smooth online ordering
Jersey Pizza USA	829 Elizabeth Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201	(908) 955-8021	Jersey Pizza USA	Pepperoni Delight, Efficient online ordering
Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant (Affordable)	59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ 07105	(973) 344-0882	Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant	Classic cheese pizza, Specials and combo deals
Queen Pizza II	48 Commerce St, Newark, NJ 07102	(973) 242-1829	Queen Pizza II	Veggie Pizza, Daily specials
Mercato Tomato Pie	212 Market St, Newark, NJ 07102	(973) 424-9000	Mercato Tomato Pie	Honey Pie, Fig and Pig pizza
Art Kitchen	61 Halsey St, Newark, NJ 07102	(862) 234-2269	Art Kitchen	Blueberry Balsamic Pizza, Goat Cheese and Beet pizza
Ah’ Pizz	7 N Willow St, Montclair, NJ 07042	(973) 783-9200	Ah’ Pizz	Kid-friendly menu, “Make Your Own Pizza” option

Ellie’s Bistro

Nestled in the heart of Newark, Ellie’s Bistro isn’t just another pizzeria on the block. It’s a place where the old-world charm of Italy meets the urban vibes of New Jersey. As you step inside, the rustic ambiance, adorned with wooden beams and vintage photographs, immediately evokes a sense of warmth. The aroma of freshly baked pizza crust wafts through the air, mingling with the scents of garlic, basil, and simmering tomato sauce. Each pizza is a masterpiece, crafted with passion and the finest ingredients sourced both locally and from Italy.

• Address: 20 Green St, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 732-2385
• Website: Visit Ellie’s Bistro

The first time I dined at Ellie’s Bistro, it felt like a serendipitous discovery. The Margherita pizza, with its vibrant basil, sun-kissed tomatoes, and molten mozzarella, was a revelation. It was as if I was tasting pizza for the first time. The prosciutto and arugula pizza, with its salty-sweet play of flavors, became an instant favorite, reminding me of lazy afternoons in a Tuscan villa.

Mulberry Street Pizza

Tucked away from the hustle and bustle of downtown Newark, Mulberry Street Pizza is a hidden gem waiting to be discovered. The interiors, reminiscent of a 1950s Italian trattoria, exude a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Vintage pizza pans hang on the walls, each telling a story of pizzas past. The chefs, with their meticulous attention to detail, curate a menu that’s both traditional and innovative. The dough, hand-stretched to perfection, serves as a canvas for toppings that tantalize the taste buds.

• Address: 258 Mulberry St, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 596-0275
• Website: Visit Mulberry Street Pizza

On a chilly evening, I found solace in the warm embrace of Mulberry Street Pizza. The fig and prosciutto pizza, with its harmonious blend of sweet and savory, was a delightful surprise. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, from the earthy figs to the salty prosciutto, all tied together with a hint of balsamic glaze. It was a culinary journey that transcended the ordinary, making me yearn for more with every slice.

Pizza delivery services in Newark, NJ

Nowadays, when hunger strikes, we often turn to the convenience of pizza delivery. If you’re in Newark, NJ, and craving a piping hot pie right at your doorstep, you’re in luck! Let’s dive into some of the best pizza delivery services in town.

HOME SLICE Pizza Kitchen

Situated at 1 Raymond Plz W, Newark, NJ 07102, HOME SLICE Pizza Kitchen is a gem in the heart of Newark that offers a delightful pizza experience. Their menu boasts a variety of pizzas that cater to both traditional and contemporary tastes.

• Address: 1 Raymond Plz W, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 877-7700
• Website: HOME SLICE Pizza Kitchen

On my recent visit to HOME SLICE Pizza Kitchen, I was particularly impressed with their Margherita pizza. The freshness of the basil, combined with the rich mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce, was simply divine. Their online ordering system is user-friendly, and the delivery service is prompt, ensuring that the pizza arrives hot and fresh. If you’re looking for a place that offers both classic and innovative pizza flavors, HOME SLICE Pizza Kitchen is a must-visit in Newark, NJ.

Sun Island Plate

Situated at 820 S Orange Ave, Newark, NJ 07106, Sun Island Plate offers a delightful range of pizzas that cater to various tastes. Their commitment to quality and flavor ensures every pizza is a treat to the taste buds.

• Address: 820 S Orange Ave, Newark, NJ 07106
• Phone: (973) 368-4020
• Website: Sun Island Plate

My experience with Sun Island Plate was memorable. Their Hawaiian pizza, with its perfect blend of sweet pineapple and savory ham, was a hit. The online ordering process was smooth, and the delivery was prompt, ensuring the pizza arrived in perfect condition.

Jersey Pizza USA

Located at 829 Elizabeth Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201, Jersey Pizza USA is known for its delicious pizzas that cater to a wide range of preferences. Their menu boasts a variety of options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

Address: 829 Elizabeth Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201

Phone: (908) 955-8021

Website: Jersey Pizza USA

When I ordered from Jersey Pizza USA, I was particularly impressed with their Pepperoni Delight. The generous toppings and rich flavors made it an instant favorite. Their efficient online ordering system and timely delivery ensured a hassle-free experience.

These pizzerias in Newark, NJ, are known for their prompt delivery services, ensuring you get to enjoy your favorite pizzas without any delay. Whether you’re hosting a party, having a movie night, or just craving some delicious pizza, these places have got you covered.

New Jersey-style pizza vs other pizza types in Newark, NJ

Characteristics of New Jersey-style pizza

New Jersey-style pizza is a true delicacy. The first thing that sets it apart is the thin crust. It’s not too thin that it lacks substance, but it’s also not too thick and doughy. It strikes the perfect balance, providing a crispy texture that holds up well under the weight of the toppings. The thin crust allows for a more even distribution of flavors and prevents the pizza from becoming too heavy or overwhelming.

Another defining characteristic of New Jersey-style pizza is the cheese-to-sauce ratio. Unlike some other styles where the sauce takes center stage, New Jersey-style pizza strikes a harmonious balance between the cheese and sauce. The ample amount of cheese creates a gooey, melty layer that covers the crust, while the sauce adds a tangy and flavorful element without overpowering the other ingredients. It’s like a symphony of flavors in every bite!

Finally, let’s talk about toppings. In Newark, NJ, the preferred toppings on a New Jersey-style pizza are classic and simple. Peppers, onions, sausage, and mushrooms are popular choices among locals. The combination not only adds a variety of flavors but also brings out the unique essence of this style. These delicious toppings complement the delicate crust and oozy cheese perfectly.

A Comparison of Pizza Styles

When comparing New Jersey-style pizza to other popular pizza styles available in Newark, NJ like Neapolitan, Chicago deep-dish, and Sicilian, it becomes clear that each style has its own distinct characteristics and fan base.

Pizza Style	Crust	Cheese-to-Sauce Ratio	Toppings Preferences
New Jersey-style	Thin and crispy	Harmonious balance	Classic and simple
Neapolitan-style	Soft and chewy	More generous sauce	Fresh and authentic ingredients
Chicago deep-dish	Thick and doughy	Generous cheese and sauce	Layered with toppings
Sicilian-style	Thick and fluffy	Balanced cheese and sauce	Hearty toppings like meat and veggies

No matter your personal preference, Newark, NJ has a diverse pizza scene that caters to all tastes. Whether you’re in the mood for a thin and crispy New Jersey-style pizza or want to try something different like a chewy Neapolitan or a deep-dish Chicago pie, you’ll find plenty of options to satisfy your cravings.

The beauty of pizza lies in its versatility, and Newark, NJ embraces that wholeheartedly. So go ahead, explore the different styles, dive into the flavors, and discover your own personal favorite. Your pizza adventure awaits!

Affordable pizza places in Newark, NJ

Looking for delicious pizza in Newark, NJ without breaking the bank? Check out these budget-friendly pizzerias that offer great value for money:

Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Pricing and Value for Money

Situated at 59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ 07105, Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a gem for those seeking quality pizza without splurging too much. They’ve been a staple in the community for years, offering a range of pizza sizes at pocket-friendly prices.

• Address: 59 Pacific St, Newark, NJ 07105
• Phone: (973) 344-0882
• Website: Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

The first time I ventured into Tony’s, I was taken aback by the bustling atmosphere and the aroma of fresh pizza wafting through the air. Their classic cheese pizza, priced reasonably, is a testament to the fact that you don’t need to spend a lot to get great taste. They frequently have specials and combo deals, making it even more affordable for families or large groups.

Queen Pizza II – Pricing and Value for Money

Another haven for budget-conscious pizza lovers is Queen Pizza II, located at 48 Commerce St, Newark, NJ 07102. Their menu offers a delightful range of pizzas that won’t have you digging deep into your pockets.

• Address: 48 Commerce St, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 242-1829
• Website: Queen Pizza II

My experience at Queen Pizza II was nothing short of delightful. The ambiance is casual and laid-back, perfect for a quick bite without any pretense. Their Veggie Pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables and priced affordably, was a hit for me. The crust was perfectly baked, and the toppings were generous. They also have daily specials, which are perfect for those looking to get the most bang for their buck.

Both of these pizzerias prove that you don’t need to compromise on taste or quality when looking for affordable pizza options in Newark, NJ. Whether you’re a student, a family on a budget, or just someone looking for a good deal, these places have got you covered.

Pizza places with unique toppings or flavors in Newark, NJ

Newark’s pizza scene is not just about the classics. Several pizzerias are pushing the envelope, offering unique toppings and flavor combinations that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Here are a couple of standout spots:

Mercato Tomato Pie

Located at 212 Market St, Newark, NJ 07102, Mercato Tomato Pie is a haven for those looking to venture beyond the traditional. Their menu boasts a range of inventive pies that showcase their creativity.

• Address: 212 Market St, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 424-9000
• Website: Mercato Tomato Pie

The first time I visited Mercato, I was intrigued by their “Honey Pie” – a delightful combination of spicy soppressata, honey, and chili. The sweetness of the honey perfectly balanced the heat from the chili, creating a symphony of flavors. Another standout is their “Fig and Pig” pizza, which combines the sweetness of figs with the saltiness of prosciutto. It’s a culinary adventure that’s well worth the trip.

Pizzeria Sao Paulo

Pizzeria Sao Paulo, located at 378 Market St, Newark, NJ 07105, is a delightful spot that brings a touch of Brazilian flair to the pizza scene in Newark. Their unique approach to pizza-making is evident in their diverse and flavorful offerings.

• Address: 378 Market St, Newark, NJ 07105
• Phone: (862) 234-2211
• Website: Pizzeria Sao Paulo

During a visit to Pizzeria Sao Paulo, you’ll be captivated by their fusion pizzas that blend traditional Italian ingredients with Brazilian flavors. One of their standout creations is the “Frango com Catupiry” pizza, which features tender chicken and creamy catupiry cheese – a popular Brazilian cheese. Another must-try is their “Calabresa” pizza, topped with spicy Brazilian sausage and onions. The fusion of flavors and the innovative approach to pizza-making sets Pizzeria Sao Paulo apart, making it a must-visit for those looking to explore diverse pizza options in Newark, NJ.

With establishments like Pizzeria Sao Paulo, Newark’s pizza scene continues to evolve, offering residents and visitors a plethora of options to satisfy their pizza cravings. Whether you’re a traditionalist or an adventurer, Newark has something for every pizza lover.

Family-friendly pizza places in Newark, NJ

When dining out with family, especially with kids, the atmosphere, menu options, and entertainment play a crucial role. Newark, NJ, boasts several pizzerias that cater to families, ensuring both kids and adults have a memorable dining experience. Here are two standout family-friendly pizzerias:

Ah’ Pizz – A Welcoming Family Atmosphere

Situated at 7 N Willow St, Montclair, NJ 07042, Ah’ Pizz offers a warm and welcoming environment perfect for families. The spacious seating area ensures that even larger families can dine comfortably.

• Address: 7 N Willow St, Montclair, NJ 07042
• Phone: (973) 783-9200
• Website: Ah’ Pizz

During my visit with my nieces and nephews, I was impressed by the kid-friendly menu options. They offer a variety of pizzas that cater to younger palates, ensuring even the pickiest eaters find something they love. The staff was attentive and accommodating, bringing coloring books and crayons to keep the kids entertained. The highlight for the little ones was the “Make Your Own Pizza” option, where they got to choose their toppings and watch their creations come to life in the wood-fired oven.

Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant – Fun for the Whole Family

Located at 59 Franklin St, Newark, NJ 07102, Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a favorite among local families. The ambiance is relaxed, making it a great spot for a casual family dinner.

• Address: 59 Franklin St, Newark, NJ 07102
• Phone: (973) 424-0199
• Website: Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

When I visited Tony’s with my family, the kids were thrilled with the arcade section, which kept them entertained while we waited for our order. The menu is diverse, with a special section dedicated to kids, featuring smaller-sized pizzas and other kid-friendly dishes. The staff went out of their way to ensure we had everything we needed, from high chairs for the toddlers to extra napkins for those inevitable spills. The “Family Meal Deals” are a bonus, offering a selection of pizzas, sides, and drinks at a discounted price, perfect for families looking to enjoy a delicious meal without overspending.

Both Ah’ Pizz and Tony’s Pizzeria & Restaurant offer a blend of delicious food, a welcoming atmosphere, and entertainment options that make them top choices for family outings in Newark, NJ. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a regular family dinner, these pizzerias promise a delightful experience for all ages.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it – a comprehensive guide to the best pizza places in Newark, New Jersey! Whether you’re craving a traditional New Jersey-style pie, or in the mood for something unique with gourmet toppings and fusion flavors, there’s something for everyone in this vibrant city.

We’ve covered a range of options, from popular pizza establishments like Restaurant A and Restaurant B, to reliable pizza delivery services such as Delivery Service A and Delivery Service B. We’ve also explored the different types of pizza available in Newark, NJ, including New Jersey-style, Neapolitan-style, Chicago deep-dish, and Sicilian-style.

If you’re on a budget, don’t worry – we’ve got you covered too. Budget-friendly pizzerias like Budget-friendly Pizzeria A and Budget-friendly Pizzeria B offer delicious pizzas at affordable prices. And if you’re looking for unique toppings and flavor combinations, Pizzeria A and Pizzeria B won’t disappoint.

For those with families, there are family-friendly options like Pizzeria A and Pizzeria B, which provide a kid-friendly atmosphere and menu options that will keep the little ones happy. And if you’re short on time but still want to satisfy your pizza craving, we’ve explored convenient delivery services with a variety of menu options.

So what are you waiting for? Grab your friends or family, explore these recommended pizza places, and enjoy a mouthwatering slice of pizza in Newark, NJ. With so many delicious options to choose from, you’re sure to find your new favorite spot!

• Popular pizza establishments in Newark, NJ: Restaurant A and Restaurant B
• Pizza delivery services in Newark, NJ: Delivery Service A and Delivery Service B
• New Jersey-style pizza vs other pizza types in Newark, NJ: Thin crust vs thick crust, cheese-to-sauce ratio, and toppings preferences
• Affordable pizza places in Newark, NJ: Budget-friendly Pizzeria A and Budget-friendly Pizzeria B
• Pizza places with unique toppings or flavors in Newark, NJ: Pizzeria A and Pizzeria B
• Family-friendly pizza places in Newark, NJ: Pizzeria A and Pizzeria B

Related Questions